Before You Spend $20k in Renovations, Read This

Before You Spend $20k in Renovations, Read This

Before You Spend $20,000 Renovating Your Rental, Read This

Why the most expensive improvements don't always produce the best return on investment.

Rental property owners often ask us a version of the same question:

"If I renovate the property, how much more rent can I get?"

It's an important question. But there's another one that should come first:

Will the additional rental income justify the cost of the renovation?

According to Zillow's Rentals Consumer Housing Trends Report 2027, renters may be placing less emphasis on newly built and recently renovated properties than in previous years.

In 2023, 45% of recent renters considered a new or recently renovated property essential.

By 2026, that number had fallen to 34%.

That doesn't mean renovations aren't valuable. It means housing providers should be more intentional about where they spend their money.

Not Every Improvement Produces the Same Return

Imagine spending $20,000 renovating a rental property.

The improvements allow you to increase the monthly rent by $150.

That's $1,800 in additional annual gross rent.

At that rate, it would take more than 11 years to recover the original investment through additional rent alone.

And that calculation doesn't account for financing costs, vacancy during construction, or the time value of money.

Of course, renovations may also preserve property value, prevent future expenses, improve marketability, or reduce days on market or turnover.

Those benefits matter.

But the decision should be based on the complete financial picture, not simply how attractive the finished property might look.

What Do Renters Actually Prioritize?

Zillow's research found that:

  • 81% considered their preferred location essential.

  • 81% considered their preferred number of bedrooms essential.

  • 68% considered their preferred number of bathrooms essential.

  • 64% considered a preferred floor plan or layout essential.

These findings suggest that renters continue to prioritize practical needs.

A beautiful kitchen may help a property stand out, but it doesn't necessarily overcome an inconvenient layout, an unsuitable location, or a price that exceeds the renter's budget.

Focus on Improvements That Solve Problems

Before beginning a renovation, consider:

Condition: Are there maintenance issues that should be addressed before cosmetic upgrades?

Functionality: Would improvements to flooring, appliances, lighting, or storage make the home more practical?

Market expectations: What features do comparable rentals already offer?

Financial return: How much additional rent can the local market reasonably support?

Long-term costs: Will the improvement reduce future maintenance or create new expenses?

Sometimes modest improvements- fresh paint, durable flooring, updated fixtures, or better landscaping- can make a meaningful difference without requiring a major investment.

The Bottom Line

Rental property renovations should be business decisions.

At Foothills Property Management of Anderson, we believe the best improvements support the property's marketability, protect its condition, and make financial sense for the owner.

Before investing thousands into upgrades, make sure you're improving your investment, not simply making it more expensive. We’re always happy to take a look and discuss what makes sense for you and your property.

Source: Zillow Rentals Consumer Housing Trends Report 2027.

Back